Monday, October 21, 2013

Back to the future IV: Michael J. Fox encounters the Red Queen

Today is October 21th 2013. This is exactly two years from October 21th 2015! If that does not ring a bell, you better continue reading...
The movie “Back to the future” tells the story of Marty McFly (played by Michael J. Fox), a teenager living in 1985 who is accidentally sent back in time to 1955. He meets his future parents in high school and accidentally attracts his mother's romantic interest. Marty must repair the damage to history by causing his parents-to-be to fall in love, and with the help of scientist Dr. Emmett "Doc" Brown, he must find a way to return to 1985.
Thanks Wikipedia. But you can tell, interesting script. The movie was a success and the producers decided to also make Back to the future II and III, making Marty running back and forth the time dimension between 1885 and 1955 and 1985 and 2015 to prevent incidents in the past or solve problems in the future.
Unfortunately, moviemakers know little about evolutionary biology and host-parasite interactions. Indeed, Michael J. Fox is travelling through time without any assessment of disease risk. What would have happened if he had a 1985 Penicillin-resistant nasty cold and contaminated his father in 1955? He might have destroyed his father and his own present. And even worse, what if he brought back the Black Death or the poxs from 1885? Would we be able to control public health and prevent a new pandemic? According to the Back to the future script, the past Michael J. Fox is taking the DeLorean time machine again to arrive in October 21th 2015... This is EXACTLY two years from now, so we better start worrying! If you need assistance with the countdown, check http://www.october212015.com.
 
Marty and Dr. Brown trying to control the time machine in Back to the future II.
Of course we would not have written this post if we would not have started worrying already. We designed an experiment to predict the scary situation of exposure to past or future infectious diseases. And based on the results, we wrote a script for a brand new movie:
Back to the future IV!
There has always been rumors about a 4th Back to the future movie. But what probably has been lacking so far, is a good script indeed. For financial and practical constraints, we will not be casting humans for Back to the future IV, but water fleas (although this might change as soon as Steven Spielberg starts begging to collaborate). Water fleas (Daphnia magna) are small crustaceans living in ponds and lakes, where they graze phytoplankton. After the summer when food becomes scarce, they start producing eggs that sink to the bottom, where they stay until there are good conditions to hatch. This is usually the next spring. However, a large fraction of the eggs does not hatch at all, but gets trapped in the mud. Year after year layers of mud with trapped eggs accumulate at a certain sedimentation speed, with older eggs in the deepest layers and more recent eggs in the top layers. So, generation after generation, water flea eggs become archived in the sediment. Interestingly, these eggs can remain viable for a very long time. So, if you go to a lake, sample an undisturbed sediment core, put the mud of the core into slices, filter out the water flea eggs, and put them into an incubator, the eggs will hatch, even those which got trapped back in 1985. And hence, with a sediment core and an incubator you can build a time machine that allows bringing water fleas... back to the future!
Now this is not only possible for the water fleas, but also for some of their parasites, such as bacterial spores that cause infectious diseases. Simply exposing the water fleas to some of the mud can be sufficient to infect them with a nasty disease. And hence, all kind of wild scenarios of exposure of hosts to past or future parasites can be investigated by performing time-shift experiments with water fleas and their parasites. This concept is particularly interesting for the study of coevolution between hosts and parasites, i.e. the evolutionary changes that host and parasites undergo in response to each other. Back to the future IV will bring a particularly interesting scenario of host-parasite coevolution, known as the "Red Queen hypothesis". This hypothesis states that coevolution between hosts and parasites proceeds as a never-ending arms race, similar to the never-ending race between the character of Alice and the Red Queen in Alice in Wonderland. This race, which we refer to as "Red Queen dynamics", occurs at the genetic level (i.e. host genotypes against parasite genotypes), and is characterized by fluctuating cycles of infectivity: sometimes a parasite genotype performs well, but causes its preferred host genotype to go down, such that another host genotype takes over. But this also allows another parasite genotype to go up, which then facilitates the come back of the first host genotype. And so on.

A perfectly healthy Daphnia magna (photo credit: Joachim Mergeay). Let's hope Marty's intestines look as healthy upon arrival on October 21th 2015...
The experiment we performed for Back to the future IV adds a surprising insight to this. Sending water fleas from the oldest layer of the sediment core forward in time by exposing them to parasites from all future layers, we observed very different levels of infectivity, i.e. Red Queen dynamics with strongly fluctuating cycles of infectivity. In contrast, sending water fleas from the most recent layer of the sediment core back in time by infecting them with parasites from all past layers, we observed much less variation in infectivity levels, i.e. Red Queen dynamics with dampened cycles of infectivity. 

We tried to explain this asymmetry with something that no movie director has tried before to convince Hollywood - a mathematical model! We simulated a number of factors that might have been different between the water fleas from the oldest layer and the most recent layer, as this was essentially the only difference between the treatments. Crucially, the water fleas from the recent layer can be regarded as experienced hosts with respect to the parasite, while water fleas from the oldest layer are actually naive hosts. The model revealed that Red Queen dynamics most likely stabilize due to an accumulation of resistance alleles over time. The gain in experience from naive hosts in the past to experienced hosts in the present hence seems modulated by a larger arsenal of genes enhancing the host performance in its coevolution with the parasite.
So how do our findings help us to plan ahead Mr. Fox’s time travel from the past to 2015? It seems like infections with parasite strains from the past have predictable outcomes, since we are all relatively experienced hosts and we may have built molecular defences to fight the disease. So a big quarantine cage to welcome Mr. Fox would probably not be needed. In contrast, Mr. Fox might be at risk himself, as infection of human hosts from 1985 with 2015 bacteria might have very unpredictable outcomes. And of course, we have to prevent him to travel back to 1985 in a bad shape, as a 2015 disease might cause a pandemic for our parents and our younger selves.
We are now waiting anxiously for Hollywood to call us. We anticipate that they will be thrilled as our script also embraces a general principle of the importance of biological diversity in evolution and ecology. In community ecology, larger species richness leads to a greater stability of ecosystem properties. For host–parasite interactions, this is illustrated by the ‘dilution effect’: a negative correlation between host biodiversity and disease risk. Our results suggest that a similar mechanism might stabilize host–parasite dynamics at a lower level of diversity, i.e. at the level of genetic diversity within host species.
Coming soon... but hopefully before October 21th 2015!
Back to the future IV
Michael J. Fox encounters the Red Queen
based on 
Ellen Decaestecker, Herbert de Gersem, Yannis Michalakis & Joost Raeymaekers (in press). Damped long-term host–parasite Red Queen coevolutionary dynamics: a reflection of dilution effects?  
Ecology Letters.
For those that cannot wait, our script is available here.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Solving the Paradox of Stasis

I've just had a paper with Andrew published in Evolution (presently in Early View), entitled “Solving the paradox of stasis: Squashed stabilizing selection and the limits of detection” (Fig. 1).  I think it might be of general interest, so I'm going to write a little about it here.  For much more, and lots of references, you can of course see the paper itself!

Figure 1. A wordle of our paper.

The paradox of stasis

The first question, of course, is “What is the paradox of stasis?”  It sounds like something from a sci-fi action movie (Fig. 2), but in fact it’s an observation about the fossil record.  As far back as Darwin, it has been observed that species in the fossil record often appear morphologically constant over very long timescales; that’s the stasis part.  This observation has been discussed extensively in the context of Gould and Eldredge’s “punctuated equilibrium” hypothesis, but regardless of what one thinks of the specifics of that hypothesis, the pattern remains in the fossil record, demanding explanation.



Figure 2.  The Paradox of Stasis, starring Matt Damon (and co-starring, clockwise from Damon's shoulder, a tuatara, a gingko leaf, a coelacanth, an echidna, and an ammonite).  Not coming to a theater near you any time soon.  Disclaimer: I am not a paleontologist, but yes, I realize that the use of “living fossils” here is not very scientific.  But it's funny, I hope, and it gets the point across.  For more rigorous examples of stasis in the fossil record, please see the academic literature.

As for the paradox part, it’s because the reason for this pattern of stasis is quite unclear.  With the world always in flux, with volcanoes and ice ages and floods and, of course, the ongoing race for fitness embodied by the Red Queen hypothesis, why would a species stay the same for such a long periods of time?  This paradox has only gotten sharper in recent years, with the frequent observation of contemporary evolution occurring before our very eyes.  If we can watch species in nature change rapidly, in response to environmental changes such as fluctuations in yearly rainfall – as the Grants documented extensively in Darwin’s finches – why does that rapid change not add up to visible change in the fossil record?  The more you ponder it, the more paradoxical it seems.

This paradox has inspired quite a bit of discussion in the literature, and many explanations have been advanced.  Without getting into details (see the paper for citations), perhaps the most broadly compelling explanation for evolutionary stasis is the presence of stabilizing selection over long periods of time; that stabilizing selection would keep a species close to its optimum “fitness peak” despite the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune.  Why such stabilizing selection might persist is a very interesting question that is beyond our discussion here; again, see the paper for cites.


Detection of stabilizing selection in nature

What I want to focus on, instead, is a difficulty that this explanation has run into, and that is that stabilizing selection is infrequently detected in studies of selection in natural populations.  Furthermore, when quadratic selection is detected in nature, it is disruptive selection about as often as it is stabilizing selection.  This is exemplified by the results of Kingsolver et al. (2001), a meta-analysis that gathered selection gradients from a large number of studies of natural selection in the wild (Fig. 3).


Figure 3.  Frequency distribution of quadratic selection gradients (γ) from Kingsolver et al. (2001; their Fig. 8).  Note that most estimates are non-significant (gray), and that both non-significant and significant estimates are fairly symmetrically distributed among values indicating stabilizing selection (negative γ) and values indicating disruptive selection (positive γ).

This observation has been a major obstacle to the acceptance of stabilizing selection as a solution to the paradox of stasis.  Enrico Fermi famously asked, in regards to arguments that intelligent life ought to be common in the universe, “Where is everybody?”, and that question has come to be known as the Fermi Paradox.  Similarly, the results of Kingsolver et al. (2001), borne out by later meta-analyses with even larger samples, point to the question: “Where is all the stabilizing selection?”


Our model

That’s what we set out to answer.  To do it, we followed what Zurell et al. (2010) called the “virtual ecologist” approach: we simulated a population under stabilizing selection, and conducted simulated mark-recapture surveys on that population, and then used regression to measure the selection detected on it, just as a field biologist would do for a real population in nature.  Indeed, we did this a lot: we ran some 2,764,800,000 regressions, covering many runs of the model each executed for 50,000 generations.  This gave us a nice big dataset that told us about the pattern of detection of stabilizing and disruptive selection for many different combinations of model parameters.  The advantage of this modeling approach stems from the fact that we know that the population is actually under stabilizing selection, since we wrote the code.  That lets us find out what pattern of selection is detected on such a population, exploring the efficacy of standard methods for detecting selection.


We did some model runs with only a simple stabilizing fitness function, but we also did a matching set of runs with negative frequency-dependent selection due to competition, added on to that underlying stabilizing fitness function.  In other words, all runs used a stabilizing fitness function, but half of them used negative frequency-dependent selection as well.  Some might be wondering: what is negative frequency-dependent selection?  Since it’s a central theme of this paper, allow me to digress for a moment.


Negative frequency-dependent selection

Sometimes selection can be thought of as a constant function: given the phenotype of an individual, the function tells you the expected fitness of that individual.  For example, stabilizing selection means that extreme phenotypic values have low expected fitness, while intermediate phenotypic values, close to some optimum value, have higher expected fitness.  But sometimes selection is not a constant function like this; sometimes it depends on the phenotypes of all of the other individuals in the population.  This is called frequency-dependent selection (Fig. 4).  It is thought that frequency-dependent selection can be generated by many ecological interactions: competition, predation, parasitism, sexual selection, and environmental heterogeneity, to name a few.


Figure 4.  A video of negative frequency-dependent selection combined with an underlying stabilizing fitness function.  The x axis is some phenotypic quantitative trait.  The black curve above represents the composite fitness function; here, the y axis is fitness.  The bars below represent the frequency of phenotypes in the population; here, the y axis is abundance.  What can be seen is that the population is subjected to disruptive selection, due to the negative frequency-dependent selection, but that it is held at the fitness minimum by the underlying stabilizing selection.  The population will thus exhibit evolutionary stasis, but a standard survey of it will indicate that it is under disruptive selection (if any selection at all is detected).  We call this combination of stabilizing selection and negative frequency-dependent selection “squashed stabilizing selection”.

So how does it work?  Competition is an easy example, so I'll use that.  Imagine that you're a bird, and there are different sizes of seeds in your environment.  You have a beak that makes you good at eating medium-sized seeds; the big seeds are too hard for you to crack, and you can’t eat small seeds fast enough to maintain your body weight (like a human trying to survive by foraging in a complex environment for one grain of rice at a time).  If many other individuals in your population also have medium-sized beaks, you'll have lots of competition for your food, and your fitness will likely be low.  If they all have beaks different from yours, though, then you're golden; they'll eat the small seeds and the big seeds, and you'll get all the medium-sized seeds you want.  So when your phenotype is common, your fitness is low; when it is rare, your fitness is high.  This is negative frequency-dependent selection, and although it is difficult to measure in nature, and has thus been confirmed in only a few cases, theory suggests that it ought to be very common.


Our results

As you might imagine, the details of our results get rather complicated, and I’ll refer you to the paper for them.  Here I’ll just jump right to the take-home points.


Figure 5.  Frequency distribution of quadratic selection gradients (γ) from our results (Haller and Hendry 2013; adapted from their Fig. 5).  The left panel shows gradients from model runs without competition; the right panel shows gradients from model runs with competition (modeled as negative frequency-dependent selection).  White bar areas are non-significant γ estimates, black bar areas are significant γ estimates, similar to Fig. 3.

Fig. 5 shows a summary of our results relating to the detection of quadratic (i.e. stabilizing and disruptive) selection.  The first thing to notice is that both with and without competition, quadratic selection is detected fairly infrequently, even though the modeled population was subject to a stabilizing fitness function in every generation.  So the infrequent detection of stabilizing selection in natural populations is not evidence that natural populations are usually not under stabilizing selection; instead, it is just a consequence of how difficult it is to detect selection using standard methods.  We give five reasons why this might be the case, and present a little evidence from our model results showing that each one is a plausible explanation: (1) well-adapted populations have few individuals of extreme phenotype, and thus experience few selective deaths and exhibit a statistically weak signature of the stabilizing selection they have adapted to, (2) populations on adaptive peaks wander in the vicinity of the peak, experiencing fluctuating directional selection rather than stabilizing selection (although this directional selection is really a manifestation of a stabilizing fitness function), (3) selection on other uncorrelated traits, and random stochasticity in fitness, generates noise that obscures the signal of selection on the focal trait, (4) the small sample sizes often used in empirical studies of selection have low statistical power, and (5) negative frequency-dependent selection might flatten or even dimple down the fitness peak, producing either detection of disruptive selection, or no detection of quadratic selection at all (because detection of stabilizing selection and detection of disruptive selection are in conflict; one cannot detect both simultaneously using standard regression-based methods).

The other thing to notice in Fig. 5 is that without competition, when selection is detected it is usually stabilizing, but with competition, it is usually disruptive – even though the underlying stabilizing fitness function is still present.  This implies that the pattern of quadratic selection observed in nature (Fig. 3) could be explained if natural populations are sometimes subject to negative frequency-dependent selection and sometimes are not.  Otherwise, it is difficult to explain the frequency with which disruptive selection is detected in nature; as Fig. 5 shows, it is very unlikely to be detected on a population that is not subject to negative frequency-dependent selection.  (There are strong reasons to think that disruptive selection that is not due to negative frequency-dependence should be very rare in nature; see the paper for discussion.)


Solving the paradox of stasis

We do not, of course, solve the paradox of stasis in this paper; no theoretical paper could ever do that, since it is fundamentally an empirical problem.  What we have done is to remove a major objection to stabilizing selection as the solution to the paradox.  We have shown that if natural populations are commonly under stabilizing selection, and are also under negative frequency-dependent selection fairly often, the overall pattern of selection that we should expect to detect is, in fact, similar to the pattern seen by Kingsolver et al. (2001) – infrequent detection of quadratic selection, divided between stabilizing and disruptive.  Stabilizing selection could, therefore, be the cause, or a major cause, of evolutionary stasis.

One implication of the paper is therefore that stabilizing selection is a viable contender for the solution to the paradox of stasis.  The other major implication is that “squashed stabilizing selection” – a combination of stabilizing selection and negative frequency-dependent selection – should be common in nature.  We suggest that looking for this pattern in empirical studies of selection might be a fruitful path forward.


References:

Haller, B. C., and Hendry, A. P.  2013.  Solving the paradox of stasis: Squashed stabilizing selection and the limits of detection.  Evolution.  DOI: 10.1111/evo.12275

Kingsolver, J. G., Hoekstra, H. E., Hoekstra, J. M., Berrigan, D, Vignieri, S. N., Hill, C. E., Hoang, A., Gibert, P., and Beerli, P.  2001.  The strength of phenotypic selection in natural populations. American Naturalist 157:245-261.

Zurell, D., Berger, U., Cabral, J. S., Jeltsch, F., Meynard, C. N., Münkemüller, T., Nehrbass, N., Pagel, J., Reineking, B., Schröder, B. & Grimm, V.  2010.  The virtual ecologist approach: Simulating data and observers. Oikos 119: 622-635.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

A survey!

Hi everybody.  Please, please, please take a couple of minutes and fill out this survey:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1GMvZP_Mkyq5QVHVy8tcU3ZwmXHR9liDo-3A16Tat3UU/viewform

I’m collecting opinions and experiences regarding the interaction between theoretical and empirical work.  This will be part of a paper I am working on with some collaborators; more on that later.  For now, I’d prefer not to say much about it.

Also, I would greatly appreciate it if you would share this survey in whatever way you have available to you, including Facebook, Twitter, and blogs.  I’m looking for responses from anyone and everyone who works in ecology and/or evolutionary biology.  You can share a link back to this post, or you can share the link to the survey itself, if you prefer.

Thanks!  As a reward, here is a picture of bristlecone pines.

Photo credit: Ben Haller.

Friday, October 4, 2013

Evaluating Ph.D. advisors

Wondering how to find a good Ph.D. advisor?  Stuck with an advisor you can’t stand?  A friend was complaining to me recently, and a funny thought occurred to me: never once, in the course of my three and a half years at McGill, did anybody in an official position ever ask me to evaluate my advisor, Andrew Hendry.  Nobody in the administration ever asked me about my experiences with him, whether I would recommend him to others, what his strengths and weaknesses are... nothing.


The nine types of PhD advisor (actually, I think there are a lot more than nine!).  Which type is your advisor – or which type are you?  (Click to see at larger size.)

Now, to get the suspense out of the way, I thought Andrew was a great advisor – for me.  Everybody has different needs, and every type of advisor has their pros and cons.  Andrew was a perfect fit for me, and as a result, I mostly enjoyed my PhD (and when I didn’t, it wasn’t his fault), and I was productive, and so forth.  The key thing in achieving this nirvana-like state is to evaluate yourself honestly, and look for an advisor who is right for you – even if that means saddling yourself with a slave driver or a control freak.  With the wrong advisor, you might get dragged through an awful experience that burns through years of your life, only to drop out without the degree.  You don’t want to be That Guy.


That Guy.

But that’s not really what I want to talk about.  I want to talk about evaluation of advisors.  It would be useful to know what type of person a prospective advisor is, and sometimes it can be hard to get a good read.  Furthermore, there are some types of advisors that really don’t have pros and cons; they only have cons.  They’re not shown in that comic up above, but you know what I’m talking about.  The egomaniac, who will take credit for your work and will try to keep you from being first author on your own papers.  The sexist pig, who will horrify and humiliate you and make your lab a living hell.  The flake, who will not live up to their commitments and will make it impossible for you to progress.  And so forth.  How can you dodge these types of advisors?

In the present system, the best way – really the only way, unless you are an exceptional judge of character – is to talk at length with your prospective fellow grad students when your prospective advisor is not in the room.  But that requires that you do an in-person visit (a lot of people wouldn’t complain about their advisor over email), and it requires some degree of trust and honesty all around (with people you probably just met that day), and it can be hard to get the advisor out of the room in a short visit – and of course the prospective advisor might be a great fit for your prospective grad students but a terrible fit for you, or vice versa.

The present system: how to know which advisor to avoid.  (Click to see at larger size.)

What occurred to me just now is: why on earth doesn’t the university administration take any interest in evaluating advisors?  During my undergrad, at the end of every course I took I was given an evaluation form to fill out, asking for feedback on all sorts of details about the quality of teaching I had experienced.  I think that form was four pages long, and I must have filled out 30 or 40 of them.  Those forms then went into the official record, and were used in tenure evaluations and departmental planning and all sorts of things.  Compare that to the feedback that was asked of me regarding Andrew as an advisor: None.  Nada.  Zip.

Wouldn’t it make sense for such evaluations to be requested at the end of one’s time as a PhD student?  Indeed, wouldn’t it make sense for annual committee meetings to be an opportunity to discuss the advisor’s performance, as well as the student’s, since both sides of the relationship need to be functional?  I can see huge issues with lack of anonymity, and revenge exacted in response to negative feedback, and so forth, and so it would have to be an optional process, and perhaps the advisor themselves could never be allowed to see the results directly; it might have to be filtered and time-delayed and anonymized to provide a safe context for the student to be honest.  Maybe the feedback couldn’t be given to the advisor until a few years after the student had left their lab.  Nevertheless, doesn’t this seem like something that ought to happen?  Such a process would let advisors who care about their performance receive suggestions and feedback from their students – feedback they are unlikely to get otherwise.  It would let departments evaluate the quality of advising of their tenure-track faculty, so they could choose not to offer tenure to advisors who made their students miserable.  And if these feedback forms were available online, it would provide an invaluable source of information for students trying to decide which lab to choose.

As the system works now (or fails to work, more accurately), my friend – who is not at McGill, I should state – is halfway through a PhD with an advisor with whom they are utterly incompatible.  They didn’t see it coming because they were unable to get a read on their advisor’s personality ahead of time.  Now they're stuck with a choice: another two years of misery, or an attempt to switch labs or even schools, or drop out and become That Guy.

Can’t we do better than this?

Friday, September 27, 2013

The emerging synthesis of evolution with ecology in fisheries science


[ This post is by Dylan Fraser of Concordia University, Montréal; I am just posting it for him.  –B. ]


It is both a harrowing and hopeful time to be a conservation biologist: harrowing in the sense that our species is, of course, rapidly altering and diminishing the Earth’s biodiversity and ecosystems. But there is hope: the present and next generation of conservation biologists really do have the opportunity to help stem the incoming tide of rapid species loss and habitat change, and to contribute substantially towards more effective conservation strategies for retaining the services that species provide to humanity. Why am I optimistic that we can accomplish this? In part, our science is getting better. It is becoming more integrative and closer to biological reality. In particular, as many of the postings on this blog indicate, we are currently witnessing the emergence and crystallization of a true (and long-awaited) synthesis of evolutionary with ecological perspectives in the scientific literature.



The implications of this ecological-evolutionary synthesis for how we manage our own activities are profound. Perhaps this is nowhere more apparent than in fisheries and its associated activities. No other vertebrates are tinkered with more by us than fishes, save for lab mice and farm animals. Intentionally or unintentionally, we harvest vast numbers of fish in marine and freshwater, we rear and release them in enormous numbers in nature for aquaculture or to bolster natural populations, we block fish migrations when we build our dams, we routinely pollute their environments, and we regularly introduce fishes to new environments. As I summarize in a recent perspective paper in the Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, such activities regularly generate rapid changes to population abundance, density, and (or) mortality. Under such conditions, evolutionary dynamics might strongly influence ecological dynamics and vice versa within fish populations, and within the communities and ecosystems they inhabit. Indeed, the evidence is accumulating that human-induced evolutionary changes in fisheries-related activities can elicit a rich array of ecological changes on short time scales, in some cases equal to or exceeding the changes brought on by classical ecological effects.

These changes are not merely of academic interest. They matter to everyone because they can and do affect the persistence, recovery and productivity (and profitability) of exploited fishes, and hence the services that fishes provide to us for our own survival and health. Once again, there are profound implications of applying ecological-evolutionary science to manage our own activities, as exemplified by a growing number of studies in fisheries science.


I am certainly not the first person to plead for more consideration of evolutionary perspectives with ecological ones in fisheries management (or any other natural resource management sector). I have found other such pleas in the literature going back at least two decades. The reality, though, is that despite such pleas, and although I firmly sense that conservation/applied biology has become more oriented toward the ecological-evolutionary perspective in many instances, management decision-making often has not (as was raised by the one of the reviewers of my paper). Why is this? Is it that evolution is still often viewed as happening too slowly to be of relevance to many management timescales? Perhaps increased recognition of evolutionary change may reveal that the current way of doing things needs tweaking, but isn’t that consistent with adaptive management? I am optimistic that the growing arsenal of studies demonstrating the significance of evolutionary change to managed species’ demography and productivity will eventually lead to more, and more positive, management decision-making change. So for those of you with a genuine interest in conducting and applying combined ecological-evolutionary science for conservation and natural resource management: keep at it! And get the message out!

References

Fraser, D. J.  (2013).  The emerging synthesis of evolution with ecology in fisheries science.  Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 70(9), 1417-1428.  DOI: 10.1139/cjfas-2013-0171

Photos provided by D. Fraser.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

A brand new bandwagon: a lifetime of ASN (and SSE and CSEE)

Scientific societies are cool things to be part of. You get free access to their journals, you have low (or no) page charges when publishing in their journals, you get cheap registration at their conferences, you get to have all sorts of wonderful interactions with colleagues, and - perhaps most important - you get to be a part of something bigger. Ever since I started as a graduate student, I have been enamored with all of these benefits and have been a member of a number of societies, with examples including the American Fisheries Society (AFS), the Ecological Society of America (ESA), the Society of the Study of Evolution (SSE), the American Society of Naturalists (ASN), the European Society of Evolution Biology (ESEB), and the Canadian Society of Ecology and Evolution (CSEE). Great fun.

Twenty years on and in the midst of all those crazy little administrative things that faculty members have to do, it has gotten annoying to have to renew these memberships each year. I frequently forget to re-up even when I want to keep dating a journal and then journals I stop dating keep pestering me. What a pain.

The solution came to me a few years ago - become a lifetime member. You get all of the above benefits and none of the above annoyances. And it is cheaper in the long run . For CSEE, annual membership is $50 per year and a lifetime membership is $800 per year - 16 years and I start saving money! Given my anticipated long life span (see this analysis), I will save tons of money. At SSE, it will take only 17.5 years. The hitch, of course, is that even if one saves money in the long run, it might be too expensive in the short run. Fortunately, McGill has a "Professional Development Fund" that gives $500 per year for professional development, which includes society memberships.

So, a few years ago, I started chipping away at the societies. I first bought a life time membership in CSEE - how could I not, given that I was on their council? Then I waited two years for the fund to build up again and bought one to SSE - I was an editor at Evolution after all. Then I waited two more years and bought one for ASN. Oops, no I didn't. They didn't have a lifetime option. Damn. Well, what to do? At this point, I was so used to not buying yearly society memberships anymore that I decided to protest. I emailed ASN and said that I wanted to be a lifetime member but because that wasn't an option, I was not going to be a member until it was. I suspect that my personal protest didn't have much effect but I was told this was already under consideration.

I just checked today and - yes - you can now become a lifetime member of ASN!!!!!!!! Within half an hour I had registered and paid - $700 (plus tax) for life versus $40 (plus tax) per year. Twenty years from now and I will be golden. In fact, I will start saving money at about the "normal retirement date" of 65. Too bad I couldn't have started with ASN first.

Although it only took half an hour, as just noted, it really should take only 5 minutes - so why the difference? Well, the problem was that the lifetime option was on the ASN website but wasn't available when I tried to pay. A few emails later (thanks Dan and Trish) and the problem was fixed - which got me to thinking - was I the first? So I emailed Trish and Dan and they confirmed it. I am the first ever (non-honorary) lifetime member of ASN. Yeeha - something to put in my obituary, which is hopefully far enough away that I start saving money on my membership.

The take home message of this post is to join the lifetime bandwagon. Get that lifetime membership and never have to worry about those renewals (and renewal notices) ever again! Do it now so that you can start saving money before you go out to pasture. And - if you do it now - you can be the second-ever (non-honorary) lifetime member of ASN!!!

Some membership links:
ASN
SSE
CSEE
ESEB - doesn't seem to have a lifetime membership - I guess I will protest there now
ESA - the link wasn't working


Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Darwin jumped on a bandwagon


I was surfing the web and noticed something interesting on Jonathan Davies' home page - rare, I know. I repeat it here with Jonathan's permission.

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Darwin jumped on a bandwagon, Mendelian genetics retarded the expansion of evolutionary theory, and the recent resurgence of interest in fruit.

Google’s Ngram viewer (http://books.google.com/ngrams/) provides a fascinating insight into the changing frequency of occurrence of keywords through time, mining the vast information database that is Google Books.

As someone with an interest in ecology and evolution, I thought it might be fun to map their trends. Because I was not sure what biases might exist in the database, I also included what I thought would be a neutral keyword ‘fruit’.



Here is my very non-scientific interpretation of what I found. Evolution is much more popular than ecology, and even overtook fruit in the 1960’s. The rise of evolution predates publication of the Origin of Species, suggesting Darwin jumped on the evolution bandwagon. Mendelian genetics and a better understanding of inheritance temporarily stalled evolution’s growth, which only recovered after Watson & Crick’s publication on the structure of DNA. Evolution continued to gain in popularity up until around 2000, at which point both ecology and evolution decline but there is a resurgence of interest in fruit – just a coincidence?

 -------------------------------------------------------------------

For more details and erudition, see Jonathan's website.

To see Jonathan dating a fish phylogeny look here.

The Null Hypothesis is Always Wrong

 No two populations are identical for any trait. No two communities have the same species composition. No detectable phenotype is ever compl...